| |
| Smooth Sailing Ahead for
Test and Burn-in Sockets |
|
Portable
consumer electronics and telecom, which appear to be the hot
IC markets going into the new millennium, will spark non-stop
growth in a buoyant socketing market. At the same time, buyers
are likely to become more value conscious as they add cost-of-ownership
to their purchasing checklists.
By
Ron Iscoff, Editor
Figure
1.
This Aries Electronics high-frequency RF test
socket features a center ground.
|
 |
The suppliers of test and burn-in sockets surveyed
for this article predict a strong market for the year ahead, fueled
by a growing demand for memory, telecom and ICs for portable electronics.
As a subset of this growth, chip-scale packages
will continue to be a key socket industry driver-but now cost of
ownership is beginning to play a larger part in the overall socket-buying
equation. Technology, too, will push the industry toward finer pitch
sockets for finer pitch devices. (Figures 1-6 show representative
sockets.)
Although we counted more than 24 suppliers a
year ago, we "lost" four in that period to acquisitions: 3M bought
Tronix; DCI absorbed Liberty Research; ECT acquired PrimeYield and
OzTek became part of Cerprobe Inc. Although there may now be slightly
fewer players, it's likely that vendors are going to face a more
competitive (read "price sensitive") environment in the year ahead.
While uniformly optimistic, socket vendors broke
ranks on how much the market for their products will grow over the
near-term. Responses varied from "considerably" to a specific figure
of 35%, forecast by Aries Electronics, Frenchtown, N.J. Nearly all
responses, however, cited-to one degree or another-the "explosion"
in handheld devices.
Consumer
Demand
Bruce DeChillo, Aries' product manager, says growth
will lean toward smaller packages, such as MLFs and CSPs. "This
growth will be driven by the enormous consumer demand for mobile
communications. Leaded device test sockets are still in strong demand,"
DeChillo adds. "These will soon plateau, however, as leadless devices-with
smaller footprints and lower price tags-take center stage."
 |
Nick Langston Sr., vice president of ATE interface
maker DCI, Santa Clara, Calif., points out that the Semiconductor
Industry Association estimates the chip market will grow by
more than 20% this year. Langston expects most sectors of
the industry, especially sockets, to be carried along by "the
rising tide."
Figure
2.
DCI's "Tspan"
is an RF emulation socket for MLPs.
|
"Moreover," Langston adds, "I believe the systems
houses-especially those driven by net-centric computing applications,
are squeezing more integration and capability into new packages,
mostly CSPs."
Second, says Langston, the consumer market is
driving the convergence of wireless and network applications, such
as stock quotes and global positioning, "so the need for more miniaturization
is compelling. This translates into more CSPs and more sockets."
David Pfaff, vice president of the Plastronics
Socket Co., Irving, Texas, estimates a "short-term increase of 20-30%
in burn-in socket demand, based on a higher number of wafer starts
this year."
Brian D. Abrams, 3M Sockets Business Unit manager,
Austin, Texas, looks for more customization "resulting from specialized
needs, such as thermal management."
Abrams believes the focus must now move from
the cost of socket acquisition to the cost of ownership. "During
the socket selection process, engineers will look to products that
include robust designs, high performance, accurate data recovery,
low maintenance and long operational life to maximize test floor
productivity."
High-Volume
Manufacturing
As competitor Ed Craig, sales and marketing
manager for Texas Instruments Interconnection Business, Mansfield,
Mass., observes, "As a supplier of burn-in sockets, the ability
to transition seamlessly from product development to high-volume
manufacturing is a must. If you miss the initial ramp, you won't
see a return on your investment."
There was little agreement by socket suppliers
on technology direction. Most concurred, however, that finer pitch
and the increased emphasis on functional test at burn-in will play
a role in their business plans.
"More and more customers are asking about doing
functional test during burn-in," notes Joe Bunch, product specialist
at Synergetix, Kansas City, Kansas. "This will drive the need for
burn-in socket makers to reconsider their contact methodology,"
says Bunch. "Low cost, short-signal-path contacts will have to be
developed to fit the need."
Scott Novak, worldwide director of sales for
ECT's Semiconductor Test Group, agrees that the increased emphasis
on test at burn-in will reduce the market for older, low-performance
contact technologies.
"Short contact, high-bandwidth probe technology
will be needed to maintain the signal integrity required by the
increasing functional integration and built-in self test demands
at the device level.
"Manufacturers will seek longer cycle lives
and generally lower costs of ownership for these types of ATE interfaces,"
Novak adds.
"With the competition for wireless technology
devices driving prices down, alternative, less expensive test and
burn-in practices will be explored," he says.
6-10
GHz Range
As several socket vendors were quick to point
out, including Jim Brandes of PrimeYield Systems, St. Paul, Minn.,
"Contactor manufacturers will focus on supplying sockets for the
last generation of communications devices in which signal frequencies
are extending into the 6-10 GHz range."
Karen F. Lynch, Cerprobe's marketing vice president,
Gilbert, Ariz., agrees that >10 GHz will be the socketing industry's
goal for communications ICs.
Additionally, Lynch says, "CSP pitches are moving
down to 0.4 mm for communications and memory applications. The need
to provide the complete interconnect solution for controlling the
electrical signal from the IC to the ATE is becoming a stronger
requirement, too."
 |
In lower-cost products aimed at the consumer
market, the emphasis will be on multiple device contacting,
according to ECT's Novak. Moreover, he adds, "Technology-specific
testers will require contact technology which can be quickly
and easily adapted over a range of device types."
Novak believes that the continuing price
pressure on packages will "further complicate the mechanical
issues with device-to-contact alignment, and force an industry
`rethink' of the traditional singular device test."
Figure
3.
Synergetix'
Ultra-Performance Rambus RDRAM test sockets
|
Plastronics' Pfaff sees burn-in focusing more
at the die and wafer level. While this technology has been developed
over nearly a decade, major obstacles still exist, he says. "Contacting
the small die pads, the number of contacts needed in a small area
and the exact method of locating the die or wafer are major socketing
issues."
Process issues, he adds, "include the excessive
amounts of heat produced in a small area, as well as the difficulty
in monitoring all the signals on a single wafer with existing burn-in
systems."
Thermal
Management
"The industry will see a tremendous advance
in thermal management for burn-in and a scramble for a reliable,
low-cost, fine-pitch interconnect solution," according to Mark Murdza,
product marketing manager for Wells-CTI, Phoenix, Ariz.
Murdza contends that the "next year will bring
0.5 mm pitch as commonplace, and we will begin to see experimentation
with 0.4 mm and even 0.3-mm pitch. The trend towards sub-0.5-mm
pitch will require an advanced interconnect technology beyond the
standard stamp-and-form contact, or even spring and probe."
 |
The trend toward "smaller, faster, cheaper"
continues for ICs, and the same holds true for contactors,
according to Randy Knudsen, product marketing manager, Johnstech
International, Minneapolis, Minn.
Figure
4.
TI's family
of sockets for burn-in includes units for LGA, SOP, SOJ, TSOP,
BGA and chip-scale packages.
|
Emerging smaller devices used in commercial
applications, specifically the handheld market, says Knudsen, are
driving speed and size. "Contactors need to interface to these small,
high-frequency packages, including several new LCC-type packages
with and without body grounds."
Although package footprints continue to shrink,
package thickness will increase due to component stacking, he says.
Ariane Loranger, sales and marketing manager
for Loranger International. Warren, Pa., notes that advances in
microprocessor speed and I/O requirements are "continuing to press
the engineering creativity and capacity of the socket designer.
Pincounts of 1000 I/Os or more are coming out faster with smaller
pitches."
Implementing
Rambus
Now that Rambus' RDRAM technology has been officially
implemented by such giants as Intel Corp., the reaction from socket
vendors is mixed, with some seeing an increase in Rambus RDRAM socket
orders. Others, however, say RDRAM interest has remained, as characterized
by Ariane Loranger, "at the status quo."
TI's Craig says orders are beginning to increase,
driven by RDRAM implementation in PCs, such as those made by Dell,
and, in turn, Dell gaining support from such major chip makers as
NEC, Samsung and Toshiba.
 |
Urex Precision, Hsinchu, Taiwan, is a
new entrant to the socketing business. "We just placed products
on the market," says Hans Ho, president/CEO Urex, "but we
are getting some requests for RDRAM evaluation sockets."
"Although inquiries for RDRAM burn-in
sockets has been minimal, 3M will introduce a Rambus RDRAM
socket later this year," says 3M's Abrams. "Our main activities,
however are focused on RDRAM test contactor projects using
our MicroTouch II product where high frequency/low inductance
performance is required."
Figure
5.
Cutaway
view of TI's Touch-Spring socket
|
Wells-CTI's Murdza sees activity surrounding
RDRAM sockets increasing slightly. "Intel has announced its intention
to use the RDRAM architecture with its Willamette processor. This
will be the first step toward a wide market acceptance for RDRAM
technology."
However, the potential influence of lower-cost
alternatives, such as Quad Data Rate and Double Date Rate memory
architectures may work against RDRAM's wide acceptance, he adds.
Competitor Aries has seen a decrease in demand
for RDRAM-type sockets, compared to an increase during Q4/98-Q1/99.
"We believe the reduction in demand is due to
the extremely volatile memory market," says Aries' DeChillo. For
that reason, he adds, "Customers do not want to make a firm commitment
to use RDRAM devices in their products."
Rambus' recent lawsuit against Hitachi may have
made DRAM suppliers leery about licensing new products from Rambus,
says Synergetix' Bunch.
Additionally, a recent alliance of big names
like Hyundai, Infineon, Intel, Micron, NEC and Samsung, formed to
develop a new DRAM architecture for PCs, has also slowed Rambus
RDRAM acceptance, Bunch believes.
Conclusion
 |
Despite a lack of agreement on RDRAM acceptance
in the marketplace, socket makers are in universal agreement
that the market for sockets-particularly those for use with
CSPs, is growing at a record rate. It seems likely that socket
providers will be further challenged not only on technical
issues, but on price issues, as well, during the coming year.
Figure
6.
Urex Precision,
Taiwan, is offering modularized CSP burn-in sockets.
|
Contact the editor at chipscale@cs.com.
|
|