| The Good, the Bad and
the Ugly: How to Select a Packaging Foundry |
|
The
"right" IC packaging foundry for your competitor may not be
the right one for you. Do you need the largest-or a medium-size-assembler?
The answer requires an understanding of how packaging foundries
operate and what services you need (and don't need) from your
supplier.
By
Gil Olachea, VisionCast, Phoenix, Arizona
|
How easy is it to find the "perfect" IC packaging
foundry for your chips? For the inexperienced, the road can be paved
with hidden minefields. Let's look at a familiar (and frequent)
scenario for many engineers who are responsible for packaging new,
advanced semiconductors:
It's a new product that a systems engineer is
designing from the ground up. The design of the final product calls
for advanced IC packages. These will require the enabling of RF/wireless
connectivity for high-speed digital data transfer and video streaming.
In addition, the package must have a smaller-than-CSP
footprint, scaleable for future chip evolutions and capable of very
high-density wire-bond interconnections. Conventional IC packaging
will not support the system design parameters.
Internal
or External Vendor?
Where does the packaging or assembly engineer
find support-inside the company or outside? Which packaging foundry
does the engineer choose? To make situations more interesting, the
engineer is employed by a 6-month-old, fabless "start-up" and this
is the first chip to debut! Maybe it isn't which foundry he chooses,
but which foundry will choose his company.
At the other end of the spectrum is the engineer
who works for a multi-national company and has a very large "velvet"
sledgehammer to leverage which of its packaging suppliers will be
awarded the challenge.
With more than 50 packaging foundries worldwide,
you would certainly consider it to be a relatively easy task to
select one that would align with the little start-up. Amazingly,
it isn't as easy as that. It is actually easier to partner with
a wafer fab supplier!
Most of the packaging foundries have difficulty
managing the uncertainty of a start-up, its low volumes and resource
demands. Additionally, the amount of attention a start-up requires
is significant.
So how does a company of any size ascertain
who or how a packaging foundry becomes a partner? The question is
simple, the answer is less so. This article will cover several facets
leading to sets of suggestions and considerations in answering this
question.
 |
With
each new generation of denser packages, wire bonding's ability
to handle fine pitch seems to increase. |
Package
Performance
The costs associated with wafer (chip-level)
integration and the reduction of line widths (lithography) demand
reviewing the buried performance merits of IC packages.
As gate (line) widths approach a theoretical
"zero," shrinking chip lithography is fiscally prohibitive. Therefore,
IC packaging is quickly becoming the focus of attention by designers,
specifiers and systems engineers.
The overall performance of semiconductors (transistor
level) over the previous 40 years can be represented by a "hockey
stick" graphic. The same is occurring with IC packaging. If we were
to plot the IC package lifeline over the past 25+ years (especially
with the latest advent in area array products) the same "hockey
stick" image would result.
Semiconductor designers and manufacturers have
realized that untapped performance can be gained by squeezing at
the package level without having to invest in multibillion-dollar
wafer fabs. The result: Package designs, innovation, variations
and proliferation are rampant. It's as though someone injected the
packaging market with fertility drugs and growth hormones!
Wireless
Markets
ICs, with their expanding abilities to support
connectivity and portability, are increasingly catering to the RF
and wireless markets.
Most packaging firms offer little in the way
of true RF parametric packages, operation or understanding. Only
a very few understand the precise placement of die, wires and passives
required to maintain consistent and continuous performance characteristics
for high-speed digital or RF products.
Therefore, it is imperative to understand the
product support requirements, from a packaging perspective, when
looking for an assembler.
The largest packaging foundry is not necessarily
the best fit for your company if it doesn't cater to your special
requirements. To this end, most packaging firms will offer a current
portfolio of mainstream BGAs and de-emphasize the "sunset" or "sunrise"
packages and/or technologies.
If your company has no need for a TO-92, metal
can, ceramic or microwave package then your choice of packaging
support is filtered to a simpler level. If, on the other hand, you
only have a need for price competitive PBGAs and the volumes are
respectable (100K per week or greater) then you can select from
about a dozen packaging foundries.
|
'It's
as though someone injected the packaging market with fertility
drugs and growth hormones!'
|
Shrinking
'Half-life'
Today, a package half-life has diminished from
decades to years. The overwhelming requirement for IC packaging
today is for mainstream packages (such as PBGAs, CSPs, QFPs, SOICs
and-yes, still PDIPs). Advanced packaging schemes like flip-chip,
modules, system-in-a-package (SIP) and wafer-scale are not the driving
force for the present packaging supply/ demand model.
Let's temper that statement a bit. We recognize
that growth on the packaging horizon exists with advanced packaging
technologies. As a result, the fabless company model, as well as
large, vertically integrated companies, is often faced with establishing
an internal packaging competency or outsourcing.
Concerns
Some of those concerns are the cost of investment,
qualification timing, reliability prerequisites, continued capital
requirements, market timing, obsolescence, and engineering/technical
resources.
Consider that it's only the top-tier packaging
foundries who have the financial wherewithal and depth to spearhead
and fund programs of emerging packages that require and consume
considerable resources.
 |
The
performance of semiconductors can be represented by a hockey
stick-including the fast and furious nature of the business.
|
|